Drive down Gault Avenue past 4th Street and you pass five buildings in about four hundred feet: a corner storefront with makers' pottery in the window, a squat brick building that hosts city events, a two-story theater with a marquee that hasn't sold a movie ticket since 1935, a small museum tucked beside it, and a pink stone depot with a caboose parked out front. If you've lived in Fort Payne any length of time, you've driven past all five more times than you could count and probably couldn't tell a stranger what's actually inside any of them right now.
Here's what's easy to miss: several of those buildings are tied to a three-year boom that began in 1889, when a group of investors bet that Fort Payne would become an industrial city on the strength of New England money. The bet mostly failed. The company that made it collapsed. Its showpiece hotel burned to the ground within a generation. And yet the modest, workaday buildings along this stretch, the ones nobody built to impress anybody, are still doing jobs in this town more than 130 years later. That's the part worth knowing before your next trip down Gault Avenue.
A Three-Year Bet Financed Out of Vermont
In November 1888, a Vermont financier organized the Fort Payne Coal and Iron Company with $5,000,000 in capital, split into 50,000 shares at $100 par value. Most of that stock sold to New England investors within five weeks of going on sale. The company moved fast: it bought roughly 32,000 acres around town, and within months a bill incorporating Fort Payne as a city passed the state legislature and was signed by Governor Seay on February 28, 1889, according to Landmarks of DeKalb County's own history of the era.
The company built a city to match the money. The DeKalb Hotel went up on Gault Avenue with 180 rooms, a billiard room, and a ballroom, and its owners reportedly turned down a $100,000 offer for it. Manitou Cave, on the side of Lookout Mountain, got bridges and stairways and a candlelit ballroom where dancers could watch the light bounce off the stalactites. An $80,000 opera house went up nearby. This was the boom, and it was meant to last.
It didn't. The DeKalb Hotel burned on February 5, 1918. Manitou Cave's ballroom faded from a destination into a curiosity. The three-year boom that put Fort Payne on paper as a New England-style industrial city ran its course and moved on, the way speculative booms tend to.
What's Actually Still Open
What survived wasn't the spectacle. It was the plainer buildings that had a specific job and kept doing it, or found a new one when the old job disappeared.
| Building | Built | Original Job | Job Today | Hours |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sawyer Building | Circa 1878-1879 | Post office, Alabama Power office, hat shop | Boom Town Makers Market | Thurs-Sat 10am-5pm, Sun 1pm-4pm |
| Coal & Iron Building | 1888 | Company offices during the boom | City-run event and exhibit space | Open for scheduled events and exhibits |
| Fort Payne Opera House | 1889 | Public theater | Theater, tours | Fri 12pm-4pm, Sat 10am-2pm, or by appointment |
| Hosiery Museum & Richard C. Hunt Hall | Housed in a building next to the Opera House | N/A, opened as a museum in 2000 | Museum on Fort Payne's sock-manufacturing era | Fri 12pm-4pm, Sat 10am-2pm, or by appointment |
| Fort Payne Depot Museum | 1891 | Alabama Great Southern Railroad depot | Railroad and county history museum | Mon-Fri 10am-4pm, Sat 12pm-3pm, Sun 2pm-4pm |
The Sawyer Building is the oldest of the group and the one that changed jobs the most. Over the decades it held the post office, the water office, the Alabama Power Company, and at one point Myrtle Bigley's hat shop. Today the first floor is Boom Town Makers Market, which opened in November 2016 and now represents more than 60 local makers selling jewelry, pottery, hand-blown glass, and gourmet food out of the same brick storefront that used to process mail.
The Coal & Iron Building has stayed closest to its original purpose in one sense. It went up in 1888 to house the company running the whole boom, and the city now uses it the same way it was always used, as a place to put on something for the public. Earlier this year, from February 20 through March 25, 2026, it hosted Spark! Places of Innovation, a traveling Smithsonian exhibit on rural American ingenuity, brought in through a partnership between Landmarks of DeKalb County, the Alabama Humanities Alliance, the City of Fort Payne, and Fort Payne Main Street.
The Opera House is the one everyone recognizes without necessarily knowing why. Wendell P. Rice, a director of the Fort Payne Coal & Iron Company, is credited with building it in 1889, and it opened on September 16, 1890, with a performance of Charles Hoyt's comedy A Tin Soldier. One old newspaper account called it
"the handsomest opera house in the state"
according to a Visit Lookout Mountain history of the building. It became a movie house in 1914 under Leona Davis, one of the county's first businesswomen, then closed in October 1935. Landmarks of DeKalb County bought it in 1969, restored it, and reopened it in 1970. It's still the only opera house in Alabama in continuous use as a theater, with a two-tier balcony that seats 448, according to the Encyclopedia of Alabama's entry on the building.
Next door, the Hosiery Museum tells the part of Fort Payne's story that came after the coal-and-iron bust, when the town reinvented itself as the Sock Capital of the World starting with its first hosiery mill in 1907. Landmarks acquired the museum from the local Hosiery Association in 2000, and it now sits beside Richard C. Hunt Hall, where the Opera House still books plays and musical performances when there's a show to put on.
Down the block, the Depot Museum is the most literal survivor of the group. Built in 1891 out of locally quarried pink sandstone in the Richardson Romanesque style, it served as an actual working stop for the Alabama Great Southern Railroad until 1970, the same year the Opera House reopened. It now holds railroad memorabilia, county history exhibits, and a set of dioramas handcrafted back in 1913, along with a caboose that Norfolk Southern Railroad donated in 1987, according to the City of Fort Payne's own museum listing.
The Buildings That Had a Job to Do
Line these five up against the DeKalb Hotel and Manitou Cave's ballroom and the pattern gets easy to see. The hotel and the cave were built to be looked at. They were the boom's advertisement to itself, proof to New England investors that their $5,000,000 had bought something grand. When the boom cooled, there was nothing underneath that grandeur to keep it standing, and the hotel burned within a generation.
The Sawyer Building, the Coal & Iron Building, the Opera House, and the Depot were built to be used. A post office needs a counter. A railroad needs a platform. A theater needs seats. When the original job disappeared, someone found the building a new one, a maker's market, an exhibit hall, a museum, because the bones were already built for foot traffic and daily use rather than for photographs.
None of that changes what shows up on a home inspection or what your closing disclosure says. But it's a decent explanation for why downtown Fort Payne still feels like a place with a pulse instead of a preserved diorama of one. The buildings that are still open are the ones that were built to have somebody walk through the door.
If you've got a Saturday morning free, the Opera House is open from 10 to 2, Boom Town opens at the same hour and stays open until 5, and the Depot is open until 3. Walk all three and you've covered a fifteen-minute loop through a story most of Fort Payne drives past without stopping for.
We spend a lot of our time at Alabama Lake Homes walking clients through Weiss Lake shorelines and Cherokee County farmland, but we're just as glad to talk about what makes a town like Fort Payne worth knowing block by block. If a conversation about property ever does come up, we're happy to have it. Until then, go see the caboose.